Madeline Miller’s “The Song of Achilles” takes readers on a deeply moving journey, reimagining an ancient Greek myth with fresh vigor. With her poetic language and sharp psychological insight, Miller redefines the timeless tale of Achilles and Patroclus, portraying them as multi-dimensional characters whose love and humanity resonate across the ages.
In this analysis, we’ll explore the multifaceted brilliance of “The Song of Achilles,” examining how Miller reimagines classic mythology for a contemporary audience.
We’ll delve into the novel’s themes, character development, and narrative techniques, drawing parallels with other literary works and considering its impact on readers.
Summary
“The Song of Achilles” tells the story of Patroclus, a young Greek prince, who is exiled to the court of King Peleus after accidentally causing the death of another boy.
There, he encounters Achilles, Peleus’ son and a demigod destined for greatness. Despite their contrasting backgrounds, a profound bond forms between them, growing from friendship into a deep love as they mature.
Their tranquil life is shattered when Helen of Sparta is taken to Troy, prompting the Greek kings to honor their vow to protect her.
Achilles, destined to be the greatest warrior of his era, joins the Trojan War with Patroclus by his side.
The siege of Troy lasts for years, during which Achilles and Patroclus face numerous challenges, including Achilles’ conflict with Agamemnon and the looming prophecy of Achilles’ death.
The story reaches its climax when Patroclus, wearing Achilles’ armor, is killed by the Trojan prince Hector.
Consumed by grief and rage, Achilles avenges his lover’s death but soon meets his own prophesied end.
The novel concludes with Patroclus’ shade waiting for proper burial, unable to enter the underworld until his ashes are mingled with those of Achilles, symbolizing their eternal bond.
Analysis
Narrative Perspective: A Fresh Lens on an Ancient Tale
One of the most striking aspects of “The Song of Achilles” is Miller’s choice to tell the story through Patroclus’ eyes.
This narrative decision offers readers a unique perspective on events that have been recounted countless times throughout history.
By centering the story on Patroclus, a character often relegated to the sidelines in traditional tellings, Miller invites us to reconsider our understanding of this ancient myth.
As I read “The Song of Achilles,” I’m reminded of Jean Rhys’ “Wide Sargasso Sea,” another novel that retells a classic story from an overlooked perspective.Just as Rhys gave voice to the silenced Bertha Mason from “Jane Eyre,” Miller brings Patroclus out of the shadows and into the spotlight.
This approach not only enriches our understanding of the characters but also prompts us to question the nature of storytelling itself.
The Evolution of Love: From Friendship to Romance
One of the most beautiful aspects of “The Song of Achilles” is the gradual and organic way in which Achilles and Patroclus’ relationship evolves from friendship to romantic love.
Miller crafts this transition with great care and sensitivity, allowing the depth of their connection to grow over time.
The seeds of their romance are planted early in their childhood friendship. Patroclus, an exiled prince, finds in Achilles a source of acceptance and companionship.
Achilles, despite his demigod status and the expectations placed upon him, is drawn to Patroclus’ gentleness and unique perspective.
Their initial bond is one of mutual understanding and comfort in each other’s presence.
As they grow older, their feelings deepen and become more complex. The pivotal moment in their relationship occurs during their time with Chiron, the centaur who becomes their teacher.
Away from the pressures of court life and societal expectations, Achilles and Patroclus are free to explore their feelings for each other.
The exact moment when their friendship transforms into romantic love is beautifully ambiguous, mirroring the often unclear boundaries between deep friendship and romantic attachment.
However, there is a poignant scene that captures the shift in their relationship. It occurs when Achilles and Patroclus are in a cave, having just bathed in a stream. Miller writes:
“I shifted, an infinitesimal movement, towards him. It was like a wave swelling. He moved, too, and our lips met. We had been silent so long that the sudden sound of his breathing was shocking. I moved closer, touched my fingers to his. Our bodies were barely touching, but even that slight contact was a burst of fire to my nerves.“
This moment is significant not only for its tenderness but for how it encapsulates the natural progression of their relationship.
The description of their movement towards each other as “like a wave swelling” suggests an inevitability to their coming together, as if their love is a force of nature.
From this point onwards, Achilles and Patroclus’ relationship deepens into a profound and passionate love.
Their bond becomes the emotional core of “The Song of Achilles,” influencing their decisions and actions throughout the rest of the novel.
What’s particularly striking about Miller’s portrayal of their love is how she balances the intensity of their feelings with the wider context of their world.
Their relationship is not without its challenges – societal expectations, the looming threat of war, and Achilles’ destiny all put pressure on their bond.
Yet through it all, their love remains a constant, a source of strength and comfort in a world of uncertainty.
Love and Relationship: The Heart of “The Song of Achilles”
At its core, “The Song of Achilles” is a love story, and it’s in her portrayal of the relationship between Achilles and Patroclus that Miller truly shines.
The tenderness and depth of their bond is palpable on every page, evolving from childhood friendship to passionate love with a naturalism that is both beautiful and heartbreaking.
Miller’s depiction of this relationship reminds me of Mary Renault’s historical novels, particularly “The Last of the Wine,” which similarly explores same-sex love in ancient Greece with sensitivity and depth.
In “The Song of Achilles,” the love between Achilles and Patroclus serves as a humanizing force, grounding these mythic figures and making their joys and sorrows deeply felt by the reader.
Keep reading: ‘A Little Life’: A Darkness that never ends
Fate and Free Will: The Tension of Destiny
A central theme in “The Song of Achilles” is the tension between fate and free will, a concept that lies at the heart of Greek tragedy.
Achilles, in particular, grapples with the weight of prophecy – he is destined for glory, but at the cost of a short life.
Miller explores how characters navigate their choices within the constraints of fate, adding depth and complexity to their actions and decisions.
This exploration of fate versus free will in “The Song of Achilles” echoes the struggles found in Sophocles’ “Oedipus Rex,” where the protagonist’s attempts to escape his prophesied fate ultimately lead to its fulfillment.
Miller’s treatment of this theme invites readers to reflect on their own lives and the extent to which we shape our destinies.
Buy ‘The Song of Achilles” on Amazon
The Cost of War: Humanity Amidst Brutality
While “The Song of Achilles” is primarily a love story, it doesn’t shy away from depicting the brutal realities of war.
Miller’s portrayal of the Trojan War is unflinching, showing both the glorified and horrific aspects of combat.
Through Patroclus’ eyes, we witness the psychological toll of prolonged conflict, the senseless loss of life, and the far-reaching consequences of violence.
In its anti-war sentiment, “The Song of Achilles” joins a long tradition of literature that includes works like Homer’s “Iliad” and more modern novels such as Erich Maria Remarque’s “All Quiet on the Western Front.”
By focusing on individual stories and relationships, Miller humanizes the conflict, moving away from the glorification often found in epic poems.
Divine Intervention and Human Agency
As in the original myths, the gods play a significant role in “The Song of Achilles.”
However, Miller’s portrayal of divine beings, particularly Thetis, Achilles’ mother, adds another layer to the story.
The gods are capricious and often cruel, viewing mortal lives as pawns in their grand schemes.
This depiction of the divine realm in “The Song of Achilles” reminds me of Neil Gaiman’s “American Gods” or Madeline Miller’s own later work, “Circe.”
In all these novels, the gods are powerful but flawed beings, their immortality often a curse as much as a blessing.
By humanizing the gods in this way, Miller creates a world where the line between mortal and divine is blurred, highlighting the humanity of her mortal characters.
I find the relationship between Achilles and his mother, Thetis, particularly fascinating.
Their interactions are fraught with tension, love, and fear, illustrating the complex dynamics that can exist between parent and child.
This aspect of “The Song of Achilles” adds depth to Achilles’ character, showing how his divine heritage both empowers and isolates him.
Achilles mourning Patrocles, John Flaxman, 1795.
Language and Style: The Poetry of Prose
One of the most beautiful aspects of “The Song of Achilles” is Miller’s prose.
Her writing is lyrical and evocative, reminiscent of the epic poetry that inspired her story.
As I read, I’m often reminded of the beauty of Homer’s language in “The Iliad,” yet Miller’s style feels fresh and accessible to modern readers.
Miller’s background in classics shines through in her ability to capture the essence of ancient Greek culture and mythology without overwhelming the reader with detail.
Her descriptions are vivid and sensory, allowing us to feel the heat of the sun on the plains of Troy, hear the clash of bronze weapons, and sense the tension in the air before a battle.
The pacing of “The Song of Achilles” is masterful, balancing intimate character moments with the sweeping events of the Trojan War.
Miller knows when to linger on a quiet conversation between lovers and when to speed through years of siege warfare, creating a rhythm that keeps the reader engaged throughout the story.
Character Development: From Boy to Legend
The character development in “The Song of Achilles” is one of its strongest aspects.
Through Patroclus’ eyes, we watch Achilles grow from a carefree boy to a troubled young man grappling with the weight of destiny.
Miller’s portrayal of Achilles is nuanced and complex, showing us the vulnerability behind the legend.
Patroclus’ own growth is equally compelling.
From an awkward, exiled prince, he becomes a healer, a confidant, and eventually a hero in his own right.
His journey reminds me of the character arcs in coming-of-age stories like Stephen Chbosky’s “The Perks of Being a Wallflower,” where personal growth is intertwined with first love and the challenges of finding one’s place in the world.
The supporting characters in “The Song of Achilles” are also well-crafted.
From the centaur Chiron to the wily Odysseus, each character feels fully realized, adding depth and richness to the world of the novel.
Themes of Legacy and Memory
“The Song of Achilles” explores the concept of legacy and how stories shape our understanding of history and individuals.
By giving voice to Patroclus, a character often overlooked in traditional tellings, Miller engages in an act of reclamation, challenging readers to reconsider the stories they think they know.
The novel’s conclusion, with Patroclus’ shade narrating beyond death, raises questions about memory, legacy, and the power of storytelling.
It suggests that true immortality lies not in godlike powers or glorious deeds, but in the enduring nature of love and the stories we leave behind.
True immortality lies not in godlike powers or glorious deeds, but in the enduring nature of love and the stories we leave behind. Share on XThis theme of legacy and storytelling in “The Song of Achilles” reminds me of works like Margaret Atwood’s “The Penelopiad” or Pat Barker’s “The Silence of the Girls,” which similarly re-examine classical myths from overlooked perspectives.
These retellings force us to confront the biases inherent in the stories we inherit and to consider whose voices have been silenced in our cultural narratives.
Keep reading: ‘The Bell Jar’: Esther Greenwood’s Summer of Dispair
The Power of Love: Transcending Time and Fate
Miller’s portrayal of the relationship between Achilles and Patroclus is so visceral, so achingly real, that it transcends the mythical setting to touch something universal in the human experience.
It’s impressive how Miller uses this ancient story to explore timeless themes of love, loyalty, and sacrifice.
The depth of feeling between Achilles and Patroclus reminds me of other great literary romances, from Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet to Emily Brontë’s Heathcliff and Catherine.
Yet “The Song of Achilles” stands apart in its depiction of a same-sex relationship in a historical context.
Miller neither sensationalizes nor shies away from the physical and emotional realities of Achilles and Patroclus’ love.
In doing so, she creates a powerful representation that resonates with modern readers while remaining true to the spirit of the original myth.
Reimagining Heroism: A Modern Perspective on Ancient Ideals
In “The Song of Achilles,” Miller challenges traditional notions of heroism. While Achilles embodies the classical heroic ideal – strong, skilled in battle, destined for glory – it is often Patroclus who displays a more modern concept of heroism through his compassion, loyalty, and moral courage.
This reimagining of heroism in “The Song of Achilles” reminds me of how other contemporary authors have revisited classic tales to explore new perspectives on heroism.
I think of Ursula K. Le Guin’s “Lavinia,” which gives voice to a minor character from Virgil’s “Aeneid,” or Geraldine Brooks’ “The Secret Chord,” which humanizes the biblical King David.
Miller’s depiction of heroism in “The Song of Achilles” aligns powerfully with modern values.
In a society that frequently celebrates strength and personal triumph, the novel highlights a different kind of heroism—one rooted in kindness, empathy, and the courage of self-sacrifice.
The Role of Women: Silent No More
While “The Song of Achilles” focuses primarily on the relationship between Achilles and Patroclus, Miller also gives thoughtful attention to the women in her story.
Characters like Thetis, Briseis, and Deidameia are given depth and agency often lacking in traditional tellings of Greek myths.
I find Miller’s treatment of female characters particularly poignant when considering the limited roles women were often assigned in ancient literature.
In “The Song of Achilles,” these women are not merely prizes to be won or obstacles to be overcome, but complex individuals with their own desires, fears, and motivations.
This aspect of “The Song of Achilles” aligns it with other works that seek to reclaim women’s voices in mythology, such as Madeline Miller’s own “Circe” or Margaret Atwood’s “The Penelopiad.”
These retellings serve as a powerful reminder of the perspectives that have been historically overlooked in our cultural narratives.
The Inevitability of Tragedy: Echoes of Greek Drama
As I read “The Song of Achilles,” I’m constantly aware of the impending tragedy. This sense of inevitable doom, so characteristic of Greek drama, permeates the novel, lending each moment of joy or triumph a bittersweet quality.
Miller’s handling of this impending tragedy is masterful.
Even though we know the fate that awaits Achilles and Patroclus, she manages to infuse their story with tension and hope.
This delicate balance reminds me of the best Greek tragedies, like Sophocles’ “Antigone” or Euripides’ “Medea,” where the audience’s foreknowledge of the outcome only heightens the emotional impact of the characters’ struggles.
The tragic elements in “The Song of Achilles” serve to underscore the novel’s themes of fate, free will, and the cost of glory.
As readers, we are forced to grapple with the question of whether a life lived fully, however briefly, is preferable to a long life lived in obscurity.
Queer Representation in Historical Fiction
“The Song of Achilles” stands out in its portrayal of a same-sex relationship in a historical context. Miller’s depiction of Achilles and Patroclus’ love is tender, authentic, and free from anachronistic modern sensibilities.
As I consider the novel’s place in the landscape of queer literature, I’m reminded of other works that have sought to reclaim LGBTQ+ narratives in history and mythology.
Mary Renault’s historical novels come to mind, as does Emma Donoghue’s “The Pull of the Stars” or Tomasz Jedrowski’s “Swimming in the Dark.”
What sets “The Song of Achilles” apart is how seamlessly the love story is integrated into the larger narrative.
Achilles and Patroclus’ relationship is not treated as taboo or as a point of conflict, but as a natural and beautiful part of their lives.
This normalization of queer love in a classical setting is both refreshing and powerful.
The Power of Retelling: Why Myths Endure
Reflecting on “The Song of Achilles,” I’m moved by the enduring power of myths and the significance of retelling them.
Miller’s novel beautifully illustrates how ancient tales can be reimagined to resonate with modern readers, all while preserving their timeless core.
The success of “The Song of Achilles” raises interesting questions about why we continue to revisit these ancient tales.
Is it the universal themes they explore? The archetypes they present? Or perhaps the way they allow us to examine our own society through the lens of the past?
I’m reminded of how other authors have successfully reimagined classic stories for modern readers – from Jean Rhys’ “Wide Sargasso Sea” to Colm Tóibín’s “House of Names.”
Each retelling offers a new perspective, breathing fresh life into age-old narratives and demonstrating their continued relevance.
Conclusion: The Lasting Impact of “The Song of Achilles”
In “The Song of Achilles”, Miller has created a work that is at once a faithful adaptation of classical myth and a deeply original exploration of love, fate, and the human condition.
Through her beautiful prose, complex characterizations, and thoughtful exploration of timeless themes, Miller has crafted a novel that resonates deeply with modern readers while honoring its ancient roots.
“The Song of Achilles” invites us to reconsider our understanding of heroism, love, and the stories we choose to tell.
In reimagining the story of Achilles and Patroclus, Miller has created a work that is both timely and timeless. “The Song of Achilles” reminds us why we continue to return to these ancient stories, finding in them reflections of our own experiences, desires, and struggles.
As a reader, I find myself profoundly moved by “The Song of Achilles.” It’s a novel that lingers in the mind long after the final page is turned, inviting rereading and reflection.
In giving voice to Patroclus and humanizing Achilles, Miller has created a love story for the ages, one that transcends time, gender, and even death itself.
Ultimately, “The Song of Achilles” is a tribute to the power of love and the lasting impact of masterful storytelling.
It exemplifies how ancient myths can be reimagined to connect with new generations while preserving the essence that has allowed them to endure for millennia.
In Madeline Miller’s skillful hands, the song of Achilles transforms into a melody that echoes in the hearts of readers, a timeless ode to love, loss, and the resilient human spirit.
Best Quotes from ‘The Song of Achilles’
- “I could recognize him by touch alone, by smell; I would know him blind, by the way his breaths came and his feet struck the earth.”
On love and connection. - “Name one hero who was happy.”
On the cost of heroism and sacrifice. - “We were like gods at the dawning of the world, and our joy was so bright we could see nothing else but the other.”
On love and transcendence. - “I will never leave him. It will be this, always, for as long as he will let me.”
On loyalty and devotion. - “There is no law that gods must be fair, Achilles.”
On the nature of fate and justice. - “In the darkness, two shadows, reaching through the hopeless, heavy dusk. Their hands meet, and light spills in a flood like a hundred golden urns pouring out the sun.”
On hope and unity. - “Achilles’ eyes lift. They are bloodshot and dead. ‘I wish he had let you all die.’”
On grief and loss. - “I found myself grinning until my cheeks hurt… This, and this, and this!”
On joy and fleeting moments of happiness. - “When I am dead, I charge you to mingle our ashes and bury us together.”
On eternal love and unity in death. - “He is half of my soul, as the poets say.”
On soulmates and deep connections. - “Chiron had said once that nations were the most foolish of mortal inventions.”
On the folly of war and conflict. - “We are all there, goddess and mortal and the boy who was both.”
On identity and duality. - “I have done it,’ she says. ‘Go,’ she says. He waits for you.”
On choices and consequences. - “His beautiful body lost to bones and grey ash.”
On mortality and the inevitability of death. - “There are no bargains between lions and men. I will kill you and eat you raw.”
On power dynamics and survival. - “He knew, but it was not enough. The sorrow was so large it threatened to tear through my skin.”
On overwhelming grief. - “Later Achilles would play the lyre… ‘I wish I had known,’ I said…”
On regret and understanding. - “Have you no more memories?” “I am made of memories.”
On the significance of memory in shaping who we are. - “I saw then how I had changed… For who can be ashamed to lose to such beauty?”
On transformation through love.
These quotes from “The Song of Achilles” capture the novel’s exploration of love, fate, heroism, and the cost of war. They showcase Madeline Miller’s poetic prose and her ability to infuse ancient myths with deeply human emotions.
